Every morning old and poor people gather before the
State Secretariat – they come travelling miles – they carry a written petition
representing their grievance and seek the Sovereign authority to redress their
grievances.. perfect – in a democracy, one needs to present their woes before
the appropriate authorities and can expect them to addressed and redressed…. But
will somebody stand before the US Embassy or Russian embassy wanting to submit
a petition ~ may sound ridiculous – only when they are ordinary citizens….
USA is anathema to many political parties
especially the Communists here… to some most global events are consequence of
US Imperialism, autocracy, monopolistic hegemony and more…. ‘anti-people
attitude’ – we condemn, we condemn…… is the slogan raised in many such
platforms. To almost all of them there is another anathema – ‘Narendra Modi’…….
The idea was to cause embarrassment to
Narendra Modi in perpetuity. It ended up embarrassing those who tried to ensure
that he does not get a US
visa instead. The Indian American Muslim Council (IAMC) which campaigned for a
letter from Indian lawmakers against Modi and supposedly obtained their
signatures, real or cut-and-paste, surely has left a lot of MPs red faced
according to this report in First Post. The
controversy around the current letter, bearing signatures of 25 Rajya Sabha
members and 40 from the Lok Sabha, first sent to Obama on 26 November, then on
5 December last year and re-sent on Sunday is because of its content. It says:
“We wish to respectfully urge you to maintain the current policy of denying Mr
Modi a visa to the United
States ”.
Adding to their discomfiture is a Washington
Post story which begins by saying: “It is almost unthinkable that Indian
lawmakers would appeal to the United
States to take a stand on an internal
matter. Most Indian politicians, many of whom still nurse a Cold War-era
suspicion of Washington ,
would bristle at the very thought of it.”
CPM leader and Rajya Sabha member Sitaram
Yechury immediately denied that he
signed on any such letter. He appeared to be at discomfort on being publicised
as being a co-author of a letter that was addressed to the American President
to respectfully urge him to intervene in a domestic political and legal issue. DMK
MP KP Ramalingam followed Yechury in issuing a denial. “I have not signed any
letter to the US
regarding Narendra Modi’s visa. I am not a US Senator. I am a Rajya Sabha MP.
Why would I interfere in their things,” he said. But then the man behind the
campaign, Mohammed Adeeb, Independent Rajya Sabha member, claims that it was
duly signed by Yechury and others. CPI MP Sayeed Aziz, too, claims that the
signatures on the letter by Yechury and other leaders are authentic.
Many thanks to Firstpost for
this newsitem and here is the one of Washington Post reproduced click here to read the original : Indian legislators petition US
Modi is emerging as the opposition
Bharatiya Janata Party’s likely candidate for prime minister in the national
elections next year. But he has been accused by international human rights
groups of looking the other way when Hindu-Muslim religious violence paralyzed
his state in 2002. Over 1,000 people died in the riots, most of them Muslims. After
widespread criticism, the U.S.
denied him a visa to visit in 2005.
Within India , Modi’s political stature has risen since
the 2002 Gujarat violence. He’s seen as
pro-business and his state hosts the factories of U.S. companies such as Ford and
General Motors. At a time when the national government headed by Prime Minister
Manmohan Singh is plagued by corruption allegations, Modi’s reputation for
administrative efficiency is serving him well. He has not expressed regret for
the riots and has said that the charges against him are politically motivated.
Many European nations have
renewed ties with him.
Earlier this week, the
president of Modi’s party, Rajnath Singh, told reporters in New
York that he will urge Washington
to reconsider the visa denial. That prompted the group of lawmakers who had
earlier written Obama to once again send their letter, which they released to
the Indian media on Tuesday.
“We wish to respectfully
urge you to maintain the current policy of denying Mr. Modi a visa to the
United States,” said the letter, signed by mostly Muslim lawmakers from several
parties, including the ruling Congress Party. “Given that legal cases against
the culprits including many senior officials in Mr. Modi’s administration are
still pending in the court of law, any revoking of the ban at this juncture
would be seen as a dismissal of the issues concerning Mr. Modi’s role in the
horrific massacres of 2002. It would legitimize Mr. Modi’s human rights
violations and seriously impact the nature of US-India relations by sending a
message that the United
States values economic interests over and
above the universal values of human rights and justice.”
The Times Now television
news channel ran a primetime debate on Tuesday titled, “Is it appropriate for
Indian politicians to drag their fight with Modi to Washington ’s court?”
Jay Narayan Vyas, a senior
colleague of Modi in the Gujarat government,
said it was like “washing dirty linen outside the country.”
“Please maintain national
dignity, we are the largest democracy in the world,” said former diplomat
Gopalaswami Parthasarathy
On Twitter, it fueled humor.
Sure it appears total contradiction of
parties who claim on every platform that US interferes, meddles and forces its
way into the affairs of every country… but they plead to the sovereign country
going against the very principle that they campaign….
If they had signed without even caring to
see to whom the petition was addressed or without reading the contents – the statement
itself speak volumes of their action…..
If they had not signed or had their
signatures been forged, it would only be appropriate that they institute legal
action against those misusing their signature….
Will any of this happen ?